How To Train Your Dragon 3 was my the majority of anticipated film of 2019. I rewatched the first 2 (plus Gift of the Night Fury) the night before, obtained all dressed up in a Hiccup cosplay, and also cancelled my prior Saturday plans to catch an progressed screening. Suffice to say, I REALLY wanted to choose it.
You are watching: Everything wrong with how to train your dragon
But I didn’t bereason I totally refuse the standard premise. All the dragons need to be covert because… um… people don’t choose dragons? And the (gigantic deadly fire-breathing) creatures are at threat from the external world? And it’s an all-or-nopoint proposition, wright here either ALL the dragons disshow up forever, or they don’t.
I call shenanigans on all of this.
Here’s the actual premise of HTTYD3: the filmdevices wanted a Toy Story 3 ending, wbelow Hiccup hregarding let go of Toothless, something beloved from his childhood. And the writers very clearly functioned backwards from tright here, creating a story and also twisting the plot into pretzels in order to arrive at that last minute. That is not just how you craft a story, and also that caused the finale to Dreamworks Animation’s ideal franchise being totally underwhelming.
Which is not to say it doesn’t still fill an emotional wallop — I was weeping in addition to the rest of the theater. But emotional wallop does not excuse shoddy storyinforming.
Berk is presented as a Viking-dragon utopia, wright here the only problems impeding their happily-ever-after are exterior risks. Putting aside my skepticism of these external risks, does Berk just have infinite room and also resources? It’s an island; inevitably they will run out of area to put all the dragons. And dragons eat many fish; ultimately the waters about Berk will certainly be overfished. The dragons keep burning down the wooden dwellings; eventually Berk will certainly run out of lumber. None of this seems to enter anyone’s mind throughout the film.
The film likewise tries to get an emotional oomph out of Stoick longing to uncover the Hidden World all alengthy and informing Baby Hiccup around it. This is the sort of point that would certainly have come up in the first two films. For instance, when Stoick is raving around finding the Nest as his ultimate dragon-fighting goal. Or at some point in the dispute over Hiccup’s penchant for trying out the Archipelback. This is a lazy retcon, a transparent excuse to acquire Stoick into the film, largely at the expense of emerging Valka’s character even more.
I’ve viewed the film’s epilogue praised as the many powerful moment in the film. Which is fair, the “share the wonder through the next generation” shtick is an extremely effective one, provided to great effect everywhere from the Very Potter trilogy to New Girl. But in this circumstances, the epilogue totally negateways the whole emotional arc of the film!
We’ve simply invested 90 minutes on the premise that dragons had actually to be covert away from the people for their very own safety (for exceptionally ill-identified reasons). We just cried around Hiccup and also Toothmuch less parting because they had actually to (for incredibly ill-characterized reasons). Well, ta-da, it’s not as significant as all that! Hiccup and also Toothmuch less get to frolic in the clouds through the following generation as if nopoint had happened.
See more: Selena Gomez Crying Face S, 10 Best Selena Gomez Crying Ideas
Are we expected to assume that the human being is currently safe (around a decade later)? Are we supposed to understand also that Hiccup and also Stormfly are the exception to the dragons’ self-applied exile? (Which would certainly be kind of awful on behalf of all the various other characters.) Or are we simply meant to wave amethod all logic, because we’re also busy feeling things?
In all, HTTYD3 illustrates all the difficulties that come as soon as you create backwards from the conclusion, instead of finding a satisfying conclusion for the story you’re informing. The HTTYD franchise set itself as much as be scrutinized by increasing the bar so extremely high: the stories, personalities, and also people were all arisen well sufficient to withstand also scrutiny. And this installment does not host up at all in the confront of scrutiny. Hiccup and Toothless deserved a much better sendoff than the one they obtained.